From clockwise top left: Crosman GI Model 1911BBb, Remington 1911 RAC (early 1911A1-style hammer and sights), Winchester Model 1911 Deluxe 11k, Umarex/Colt Model 1911
The Umarex Colt Commander airgun has all of the working features of a cartridge-firing Model 1911 pistol, including the thumb safety, beavertail grip safety and mag release.
The author demonstrates a tactical reload with the Umarex Colt Commander.
Umarex Colt Commander
Crosman GI Model 1911BBb
Remington 1911 RAC
My very first handgun was a World War II-era Model 1911, and I could not hit the broad side of a barn with it! Fortunately, there were very few barns where I lived in the Southern California desert, but there was this wonderful sand berm just outside of town that folks used as a shooting range on weekends, and it was there, over time, that I became proficient with the 1911.
The cost of that training experience, even in the late 1960s, wasn’t cheap. Over time, I improved motor skills and muscle memory by practicing draw, presentation and firing routines—exercises that include the swift but well-timed release of the thumb safety, placement of the trigger finger, activation of the slide and magazine releases, reloading, releasing the slide and reacquiring the target after each shot. I wish back then that I knew what I know now and that there had been air pistols like the Umarex Colt Commander and Remington 1911 RAC. With these air guns I could have learned a lot for just pennies on the dollar!
In terms of training exercises, there are numerous advantages to using 1911 live-action air pistols, as these duty-sized handguns operate the same way as a cartridge-firing Colt .45 ACP. Specific training regimens can be practiced with these “blowback” air pistols, right down to loading the magazine, chambering the first round and pulling the trigger. This also helps to improve skills such as trigger control and sight acquisition, particularly with this type of air pistol because the slide on the Umarex Colt Commander and Remington 1911 RAC actually functions with each shot. All that is missing is recoil, and you can see the results of your efforts with .177 BBs on your target for only pennies, rather than the cost of .45 ACP ammunition.
Gaining familiarity with a cartridge-firing pistol and its operation by using a perfectly matched air pistol is affordable and efficient, ideal for youth or remedial training, and there’s also just the plain fun of it. Once you shoot a live-action BB gun, it’s hard to stop until you run out of CO2, and, best of all, most top-quality 1911 models retail for less than $150.
The Umarex Colt Commander and Remington 1911 RAC (both are manufactured in Taiwan and share identical features) are the most exact in detail and operation to a 1911. The Umarex and Remington models are fully licensed products and are accurate down to the smallest details. Closely duplicating the physical appearance, weight and balance of the cartridge-firing models, the Colt Commander and Remington 1911 RAC pistols operate with the power of a single 12-gram CO2 capsule contained within the magazine (rather than inserted separately into the grip frame). In addition to the CO2 capsule, the precisely sized 1911-style magazine also contains a channel for 18 precision steel .177-caliber BB rounds. Extra magazines can be purchased and used for tactical reloading drills on the range.
In a blowback-action air pistol, the CO2 capsule performs two functions, propelling a BB downrange at an average velocity of 325 feet per second (fps) and operating the recoil of the slide to recock the hammer and chamber the next BB. Each pistol’s all-metal construction (including the magazine) provides a hefty feel in the hand (32 ounces), approximating the weight of a real 1911.
The Umarex model, which has an MSRP of $122, features a modern skeletonized trigger and Commander-style hammer, fixed front and rear white-dot tactical sights, a checkered/raised mainspring housing, black diamond-checkered plastic grips, as well as a fully operating beavertail safety, thumb safety and slide release.
The Remington 1911 RAC, priced at $129, features an early-style 1911 hammer and trigger, early-style front and rear sights and checkered, wood-finished grips. During WWI and WWII, Remington manufactured Colt Model 1911s to meet U.S. military demands, and today Remington makes its R1 series of 1911 models as well as lending its name to the air-pistol version. Both models have a military tether ring at the bottom of the backstrap. Every aspect of handling these 1911 air pistols is a training experience.
There are also several special versions of the Colt 1911, including the KWC Tanfoglio Witness. The KWC Tanfoglio features a raised/checkered mainspring housing, an early-style Colt hammer and original-style sights. The most interesting variation is an NRA Limited Edition 1911, which has all the features offered on the Umarex Colt Commander plus a special antiqued finish, the NRA logo and the Second Amendment written on the left side of the slide. This model retails for $200. Finally there is the Blackwater tactical version with a dustcover accessory rail, skeletonized hammer and trigger and Blackwater stylized slide. Retail is also $200. These models are identical in operation to the Colt and Remington and are available through Pyramyd Air.
One of the oldest names in air pistols is Crosman. This fabled American brand offers a full-action 1911 called the GI Model 1911BBb. This model also features a blowback action, however the Crosman is a unique design with a separate BB reservoir that holds 20 BBs delivered downrange at an average velocity of 450 fps. The exterior is based on the early 1911 GI-issued models and has a fixed rear sight and small early-style front sight. Not quite as accurate in detail, the 1911BBb does not offer all of the working features of the Colt or Remington. Instead, it uses a different style magazine, a flat, smooth mainspring housing, an oversized DA/SA trigger and a non-functioning 1911-style thumb safety. Crosman adds a manual safety of its own design on the right side of the frame that is set and released by the trigger finger. With a suggested retail of $100, the GI Model 1911BBb is also the cheapest.
The Winchester Model 11K, which is manufactured in Japan and licensed by Winchester, uses yet another variation of the blowback design. Priced at $150, the Winchester 11K is the deluxe version with a bi-tone finish (matte black slide and matte cast alloy frame). The airgun features a traditional raised palm swell and beavertail grip safety, a full-sized thumb safety and slide release, an early-style hammer and a serrated trigger, all of which are brightly finished. The most important difference between the Daisy design and the Umarex 1911s is Winchester’s traditional placement of the CO2 capsule in the grip frame and a separate stick-type carrier for BBs. Like the Crosman, the Winchester design eliminates the possibility of using the air pistol for tactical reload practice.
Airing It Out
To do a full training set, I decided to go old school and wear a World War Supply U.S. M7 shoulder holster (like William Holden wore in The Wild Bunch). Drawing the Remington air pistol from the shoulder rig, I went through the entire procedure, from loading the magazine to working the slide, setting the safety, holstering, drawing, releasing the safety, acquiring the target and firing. I also practiced magazine changes. I repeated these exercises with the Umarex Colt Commander using a Galco Combat Master belt holster. Doing these practice regimens will help anyone become familiarized with the proper handing and operation of a Model 1911.
With a target placed out at 25 feet, the accuracy of the Remington 1911 RAC and Umarex Colt Commander was consistent throughout five complete reloads (90 shots). The best average 10-shot group measured 1.87 inches with the Umarex Colt Commander. While the trigger pull is light and the recoil is nonexistent, this is still good training practice for handling 1911-platform pistols and reacquiring the sights quickly after the slide goes back into battery.
Training is essential for concealed carry. If a Colt Model 1911 was my personal preference for a concealment sidearm, having one of these highly accurate Umarex 1911-style air pistols for practice drills would be an excellent low-cost option for any training regimen short of live ammunition target practice. With an average price of $125, the cost of just five boxes of .45 ACP Winchester 230-grain full metal jacket (FMJ) ammunition would easily pay for one of these live-action air pistols!
For More Information
Remington Air Guns
Winchester Air Rifles
If you really want a master-crafted one-of-a-kind, Republic Forge's "Build Your Own 1911" program...
by Len Waldron / Jan 23, 2015