Personal Defense World
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Police News
    • Politics
    • Gun Facts & Laws
  • Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    • Shotguns
    • Specialty Guns
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
    • Rifle Ammo
    • Shotgun Ammo
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
  • Accessories
    • Holsters
    • Optics & Sights
    • Lasers & Lights
    • Suppressors
  • Gear
    • Knives
    • Flashlights
    • Storage
  • Lifestyle
    • Shooting 101
    • Training
    • Concealed Carry
    • Home Defense
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
    • Competition Shooting
  • Videos
    • Video Series
      • At The Ready
      • Everyday Carry
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Personal Defense World
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Police News
    • Politics
    • Gun Facts & Laws
  • Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    • Shotguns
    • Specialty Guns
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
    • Rifle Ammo
    • Shotgun Ammo
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
  • Accessories
    • Holsters
    • Optics & Sights
    • Lasers & Lights
    • Suppressors
  • Gear
    • Knives
    • Flashlights
    • Storage
  • Lifestyle
    • Shooting 101
    • Training
    • Concealed Carry
    • Home Defense
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
    • Competition Shooting
  • Videos
    • Video Series
      • At The Ready
      • Everyday Carry
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Personal Defense World
No Result
View All Result
 
*FREE GUN FRIDAY* Enter to WIN >> IWI Zion-15 Rifle & Black Hills 5.56 Ammo

Snubbie Shootout: Ruger LCR Vs. S&W Model 640

Richard Johnson by Richard Johnson
November 17, 2016
in Accessories, Concealed Carry, Gun Facts & Laws, Guns, Handguns, Holsters, Lifestyle, News, Revolvers
0
S&W Model 640 revolver

The Ruger LCR (left) and S&W Model 640 (right) are two quality revolvers that harness the power of the .357 Magnum for concealed carry—but which one will suit your needs better?

0
SHARES
1.7k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
S&W Model 640 revolver
The Ruger LCR (left) and S&W Model 640 (right) are two quality revolvers that harness the power of the .357 Magnum for concealed carry—but which one will suit your needs better?
S&W Model 640 pistol
Despite an unloaded weight of only 17.1 ounces, the Ruger LCR handled well during testing and was relatively easy to control.
S&W Model 640 handgun
The LCR’s front sight is a pinned ramp that is easy to replace should you want something like a fiber-optic or tritium unit, for example.

S&W Model 640 vs Ruger LCR handgun
The Ruger LCR’s barrel is only 1.87 inches long—about 0.26 inches shorter than the S&W Model 640’s, which makes it slightly easier to conceal.
Model 640 and ruger lcr
The Hogue Tamer Monogrip is made of soft rubber and features finger grooves and a pebble texture for an improved grip.
ruger lcr cylinder, model 640
The LCR’s cylinder release latch is very positive and works when the shooter touches the rear portion of the button.

ruger lcr target, model 640
ruger lcr grip, model 640
The Hogue grip includes an extra-soft cushion where the gun hits the web of the hand.
ruger lcr sight, model 640
Note the rear sight notch.

S&W Model 640 gun test
While both revolvers offered typical .357 Magnum recoil, the Smith & Wesson Model 640 had less muzzle flip and was easier to control thanks to its stainless steel construction.
S&W Model 640 barrel
The Model 640 has a 2.13-inch barrel and a black, serrated front sight blade that constrasts well with the stainless steel frame.
S&W Model 640 front sight
The Model 640 has a 2.13-inch barrel and a black, serrated front sight blade that constrasts well with the stainless steel frame.

S&W Model 640 target
Both the Model 640 and the LCR turned in their best groups with Hornady’s 125-grain Critical Defense FTX ammunition.
S&W Model 640 ejector rod
The Model 640’s ejector rod is slightly longer than the LCR’s, making it easier to remove stuck casings during a reload.
S&W Model 640 cylinder

S&W Model 640 trigger
The 640’s trigger has a strong return.
S&W Model 640 cylinder release
A lock behind the cylinder release allows you to secure the gun for storage.
S&W Model 640 test

Pocket flamethrower. Fistful of thunder. These are just two of the terms I’ve heard for small-framed .357 Magnum revolvers. Without a doubt, full-bore .357 Magnum loads are impressive in terms of recoil, noise and terminal effectiveness. Their muzzle flash can be equally impressive.

For many years, the .357 Magnum was considered the man-stopper. The 1980s saw the beginning of a mass migration toward semi-automatic pistols, and in the 1990s, bullet designs improved to the point where there wasn’t as much of a difference between handgun calibers as there once had been. The loud and proud .357 Magnum began to fall out of favor.

So, does the .357 Magnum still have a role in the modern world? Unequivocally, yes. The power of the .357 Magnum, combined with the improved performance of modern bullet designs, suggests that it may be more potent than ever. In addition, many people simply prefer a double-action revolver for self-defense. While there may be fewer snub-nose revolver buyers today, it is still a large market. Fortunately, both Smith & Wesson and Ruger serve these shooters with a pair of similar, yet very different, guns.

The Contenders

ruger revolver

When the LCR was introduced, I knew Ruger had something special. The LCR is a unique revolver with a polymer fire control housing mated to a stainless steel frame. While the frame provides the strength and durability needed in a magnum handgun, the polymer housing allows the company to shave weight from the gun. Some have theorized that the polymer also reduces felt recoil due to minute flexing in the material.

Another LCR innovation is the company’s friction-reducing cam system that offers a smooth, consistent trigger pull. Combined with a shock-absorbing Hogue Tamer Monogrip and a replaceable front sight, the LCR has plenty to offer a shooter needing a small-framed wheelgun. A matte black finish is standard.

  • RELATED STORY: Gun Review – Ruger’s New Model Blackhawk Revolver

Now for the other gun in our matchup. For decades, Smith & Wesson has made J-Frame revolvers in a range of calibers, including the .357 Magnum. One of the company’s most popular designs is the Model 640. Like the LCR, the Model 640 is a double-action-only (DAO) wheelgun with an internal hammer.

The gun uses a stainless steel frame that extends all the way down to its round butt, and is clad in a synthetic grip. The barrel, cylinder and frame all have a satin stainless finish. The front sight is a pinned ramp that can be replaced if so desired.

Both guns offer a great deal to appreciate from a self-defense perspective yet are very different. If you are looking for a snubbie magnum, how do you select between these two? Perhaps this head-to-head comparison will help.

Round 1: Reliability

S&W Model 640 ejector rod
The Model 640’s ejector rod is slightly longer than the LCR’s, making it easier to remove stuck casings during a reload.

One of the primary reasons many people consider a revolver for self-defense is reliability. While problems can occur with a wheelgun, they tend to run more reliably than semi-automatic pistols. I had high expectations for both guns in terms of reliability. When it came to making loud noise, both performed admirably. Both the Ruger and S&W fired all of the test ammunition without any problems.

There is another ­aspect to reliability, however: extracting spent ­casings. When a round is fired, the case expands to fit the shape of the inside of the cylinder. As a result, a spent case is more difficult to remove from a charge hole than it was when you slipped the unfired round into it. This is the reason the revolvers are equipped with an ejector star attached to an ejector rod—to push the empty brass out of the cylinder.

With a swift strike to the ejector rod on the Model 640, the empties were easily extracted from the cylinder and dropped free, allowing for an immediate reload. This wasn’t always the case with the LCR, however. Sometimes the empty cases would hang slightly after being extracted and had to be brushed away. It appears that the additional quarter inch or so of length on the S&W’s ejector rod allowed it to more reliably extract the spent cases.

Advantage: Smith & Wesson

Round 2: Trigger Pull

S&W Model 640 trigger
The 640’s trigger has a strong return.

You can measure the trigger pull weight, but the key feature for me is the trigger’s feel. That is necessarily something far more subjective. My test Model 640 had a smooth trigger with no perceptible take-up or overtravel. As with most Smith & Wesson revolvers, it has a strong return, so running it fast is no problem.

  • RELATED STORY: Hot 8-Shot Snubbie – Smith & Wesson Performance Center Model 627

The LCR had a smooth, and noticeably lighter, trigger pull. While the pull was not light by semi-automatic standards, it seemed much easier to stroke than other DAO wheelguns. There was a slight amount of take-up at the start of the pull with a hint of overtravel after firing. Neither of these seemed to affect accuracy.

While I liked the pull of the LCR quite a bit, the return was not as strong as that on the S&W gun. If you fail to let the trigger completely out before pulling it again, it may not rotate the cylinder to a fresh cartridge. I experienced this problem when I first shot another Ruger LCR several years ago and have since trained myself around it. Depending on your past experience with double-action revolvers, you may also need some practice to avoid this issue.

Advantage: Tie

Round 3: Accuracy

S&W Model 640 handgun
The LCR’s front sight is a pinned ramp that is easy to replace should you want something like a fiber-optic or tritium unit, for example.

Short-barreled revolvers can get a bad rap for being less accurate that their longer-barreled brethren. While there are some inherent accuracy advantages to some larger guns, many, if not most, of the accuracy problems with small wheelguns come from the shooter.

Anticipation of recoil, a shorter sight radius and a smaller grip are all things that can affect a shooter’s ability to put rounds on target.

Both of these wheelguns had greater potential accuracy than I was able to wring out of them. However, my practical accuracy with a two-handed grip was still pretty good. With all of the defensive loads I tried, both guns shot groups smaller than 2.5 inches at 7 yards.

The Hornady Critical Defense ammo was the best of the bunch in both guns, and it produced significantly smaller groups with the LCR than the Model 640. In fact, two of the three defensive loads I tested showed better groupings with the LCR, though the groups with the other loads were much closer in ­accuracy.

Advantage: Ruger

Round 4: Recoil

S&W Model 640 gun test
While both revolvers offered typical .357 Magnum recoil, the Smith & Wesson Model 640 had less muzzle flip and was easier to control thanks to its stainless steel construction.

Before shooting these two guns side by side, I anticipated that the LCR would be easier on the hand than the Model 640. After all, the Ruger had a wider grip with a special soft, recoil-absorbing area where it meets the web of the hand. On the other hand, Smith & Wesson used a narrower grip that I expected to hit the web of the hand like a dull knife. I was wrong on both accounts.

  • RELATED STORY: Gun Review – Ruger 22 Charger Takedown Pistol

I was surprised to find that it was easier to control the recoil and muzzle flip with the Smith & Wesson Model 640. All snub-nosed magnum revolvers have heavy recoil—that’s life. While the LCR was very controllable, I found the Model 640 had less muzzle flip and was easier on the hand than its counterpart. I suspect that the additional weight from the all-stainless-steel construction helped with that. Also, even though the S&W grip was thinner, it was also longer, allowing me to get my pinky on the gun, rather than curling it up underneath.

Advantage: Smith & Wesson

Round 5: Concealment

S&W Model 640 vs Ruger LCR handgun
The Ruger LCR’s barrel is only 1.87 inches long—about 0.26 inches shorter than the S&W Model 640’s, which makes it slightly easier to conceal.

Both guns are well suited for concealed carry. They are relatively small and have plenty of support from holster manufacturers. With an inside-the-waistband (IWB) rig, a belt slide scabbard or a shoulder holster, the guns are fairly equal. The only real difference is weight: The Smith & Wesson is about 6 ounces heavier.

For pocket carry, both will work in pants with large pockets. For smaller pockets, both of these guns will struggle a bit with neither being terribly good for tailored pants or fitted jeans. The Ruger LCR’s shorter grip and barrel give it the edge in some circumstances.

Advantage: Ruger

Round 6: Fit & Finish

S&W Model 640 barrel
The Model 640 has a 2.13-inch barrel and a black, serrated front sight blade that constrasts well with the stainless steel frame.

Both companies make high-quality products, and these compact snub-nosed revolvers are excellent examples. Neither gun has a clear advantage in the fit and finish category, as I could find no obvious problems with the way either was built or finished. The obvious visual difference—matte black or satin stainless—is purely a personal preference.

  • RELATED STORY: 5 Compact Smith & Wesson Handguns

Advantage: Tie

The Verdict

S&W Model 640 ruger lcr comparison

I define “value” as the point where quality and price meet, offering the maximum amount of performance for the least amount of money. A $5,000 pistol may work great, but if it isn’t any more reliable or efficient than a $500 pistol, I don’t believe it is as good a value as a self-defense firearm.

Since both the LCR and Model 640 performed extremely well, the value comes down to price in this head-to-head matchup. Ruger sets the suggested retail price of the LCR at $669, while the S&W comes in at a slightly higher $729. This gives the advantage to Ruger. However, it should not preclude the Model 640 from your list if you are shopping for a new revolver. These two guns are significantly different, and each offers advantages over the other. ­Finding the one that you shoot well, regardless of the price, is the real value.

This article was originally published in ‘Handguns Buyer’s Guide’ 2017. For information on how to subscribe, please email subscriptions@outdoorgroupmags.com or call 1-800-284-5668.

Save

Save

Didn't find what you were looking for?

CLICK HERE FOR COMMENTS

Related Posts

Nexbelt Adds the Supreme Appendix EDC Gun Belt in Black Camo.

Nexbelt Adds the Supreme Appendix EDC Gun Belt in Black Camo

The Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 10mm.

Big Bore Greatness: Testing the Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 10mm

The Smith & Wesson M&P Bodyguard 38.

Hi-Tech Snubbie: Testing the Smith & Wesson M&P Bodyguard 38

Ruger Now Offering Max-9 with Factory Installed Ruger ReadyDot Micro Reflex Optic.

Ruger Offers Max-9 with Ruger ReadyDot Micro Reflex Optic Installed

Load More

PERSONAL DEFENSE WORLD VIDEOS

Discussion about this post

FEATURED POST

Study Proves the Good Guy with a Gun Theory.

Good Guy with a Gun: Study of CCW Holders Stopping Mass Shootings

Following the tragedy in Uvalde, Texas, gun control advocates have taken the anti-gun narrative to a fever pitch. They insist...

Read more

TRENDING

gm, general motors, general motors stabbing

Michigan: Concealed Carrying Valet Saves GM Worker In Stabbing

...

We tested three of the most popular 8-shot revolvers on the market today.

8-Shot Revolver Showdown With S&W, Ruger, and Taurus

...

Two Tisas 1911 models.

Turkish Gold: Testing Two Budget-Friendly Tisas 1911 Models

...

The Magnum Research 1911.

Magnum 10: Shooting the Magnum Research G Model 10mm 1911

...

PICK A CATEGORY

CONCEALED CARRY SPOTLIGHT

Nexbelt Adds the Supreme Appendix EDC Gun Belt in Black Camo.

Nexbelt Adds the Supreme Appendix EDC Gun Belt in Black Camo

Nexbelt has brought innovation and performance to the gun belt arena in recent years. Fortunately, the company isn’t just a...

CONCEALED CARRY SHOWCASE

Wisconsin To Get a New Firearms Training Center, Mission94, in Early 2024.

Mission94 Firearms Education Center to Open in Early 2024

The Grey Man Tactical Safe Door Organizer.

Store More with the Grey Man Tactical Safe Door Organizer

25 firearm storage device options for keeping your guns safe.

Safe & Secure: 25 Fortified Firearm Storage Options

Memorial Day 2014 tribute

Memorial Day: Honoring Our Fallen American Heroes

CEO of Fenix Ammo Delivers Conditions for Free Ammo to MTOA.

Fenix Ammunition CEO Torches MI Police After Free Ammo Request

The Premier Body Armor Home Shield.

Premier Body Armor Home Shield – Protection You Can Get Behind

The Beretta 92XI SAO.

Beretta Expands Its Popular 92 Line with the 92XI SAO

Using paper targets during shooting practice for immediate feedback.

Shred It: Shooting Paper Targets Provides Important Feedback

AMMO SPOTLIGHT

handloading, handloader, handloading tips, handloading ammunition, handloading ammo

5 Common-Sense Handloading Tips

A rundown of five essentials every handloader must know before he starts rolling his own ammunition.

  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
Call us: +1 234 JEG THEME

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Guns
    • View All Guns
    • Handguns
    • Shotguns
    • Rifles
    • Specialty Guns
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
    • Rifle Ammo
    • Shotgun Ammo
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
  • Accessories
    • View All Accessories
    • Holsters
    • Optics & Sights
    • Laser & Lights
    • Suppressors
  • Gear
    • View All Gear
    • Knives
    • Storage
  • Lifestyle
    • View All Lifestyle
    • Shooting 101
    • Training
    • Concealed Carry
    • Home Defense
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
    • Competition Shooting
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Police News
    • Politics
    • Gun Facts & Laws
  • Videos
  • Subscribe

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.